You bought the flat with a mortgage. Years later, your buyer’s lender raises a problem with the remaining lease term.
Your first reaction may be understandable: if the lease was acceptable to my lender, why is it a problem now?
There are several possible explanations. The lease has become shorter. The proposed lender may apply different requirements. Your original lender may also have changed its own instructions since you bought.
Those explanations need separating before anyone concludes that the property should never have been mortgaged, that the original conveyancer made a mistake or that the flat can now be sold only for cash.
Three comparisons that can produce different answers
Start by identifying which comparison you are making:
- The same lender, at different dates: did its requirements change between your purchase and the present transaction?
- Different lenders, on the same date: would they apply different requirements to the same lease?
- The same requirement, applied to a shorter lease: has the remaining term fallen below a threshold that has stayed unchanged?
More than one explanation may apply. A shorter lease and a different mortgage term can also affect the calculation together.
1. The lease can fail an unchanged requirement
Consider a simplified example.
A flat had exactly 86 years remaining when its owner bought it. Six years later, it has exactly 80 years remaining, assuming no extension or other change.
Suppose a lender’s requirement throughout that period was at least 85 years remaining at completion. The lease would satisfy that particular condition at the earlier date and fail it at the later date.
The lender would not need to change its policy for the outcome to change.
These are hypothetical figures, not the requirements of a named lender. In a real transaction, the lease commencement date, expiry date and relevant completion date must be checked precisely.
2. A different lender may ask a different question
There is no single minimum lease term that answers every mortgage application.
Under the UK Finance Mortgage Lenders’ Handbook for England and Wales, section 5.14.1 directs conveyancers to the lender’s Part 2 requirements concerning the unexpired lease term.
Published instructions can address the term remaining when the mortgage begins, the period remaining when it ends, or both. Other conditions and the mortgage offer may also matter.
Your original lender’s acceptance therefore does not establish that your buyer’s lender must accept the property.
Equally, a difficulty with one proposed lender does not establish that every lender would refuse. Your buyer’s mortgage adviser needs to assess the available borrowing options.
The mortgage term can change the arithmetic
Suppose a lender required at least 50 years to remain on the lease at the end of the mortgage. Assume the lease has exactly 82 years remaining at the proposed completion date.
| Proposed mortgage term | Lease remaining at its end | Meets the assumed 50-year condition? |
|---|---|---|
| 25 years | 57 years | Yes |
| 35 years | 47 years | No |
This is an arithmetic illustration using an invented requirement. It is not a mortgage recommendation or confirmation of eligibility. Any separate minimum at completion and all other applicable conditions would also need to be satisfied.
The same flat, on the same day, could therefore produce a different answer under that condition because the proposed borrowing period differs.
Our article on buying a flat with an 80–90 year lease and planning the next mortgage decision considers the buyer’s wider budgeting and refinancing questions.
3. Your original lender may have changed its requirements
A lender’s current instructions are not evidence of the wording that applied years earlier.
If you want to understand the original transaction, identify the lender, jurisdiction and relevant dates. Obtain the historical instructions rather than substituting today’s answer.
The material date may depend on the question being investigated. Exchange, submission of the Certificate of Title and completion can require separate consideration.
Also establish whether there was a specific referral or approval. A published requirement and the lender’s response to the particular transaction should be read together.
First establish what has actually stopped the sale
“The lease is too short” can conceal different concerns.
Ask your conveyancer to clarify the outstanding point with the buyer’s solicitor:
- What unexpired term has been calculated?
- Which lender requirement is relevant?
- Does the problem concern the term at completion, the period remaining at the mortgage’s end or another condition?
- Has the lender refused, requested a referral or asked for further information?
- Is there a separate valuation concern?
- Is the buyer withdrawing because of anticipated extension costs, rather than an established mortgage refusal?
A buyer can decide against proceeding even where a mortgage might be available. Our account of a buyer withdrawing over a reported 91-year lease explains why those situations should not be confused.
What can the historical Archive establish?
The Lexsure Lender Archive’s short-lease topic page is a starting point for researching dated lender requirements.
Subject to coverage, the Lender Snapshot supplies the lender’s complete historical Part 2 record for the selected date. The Market Context Report adds other applicable lenders’ recorded wording on the selected issue for that same date.
This can help distinguish your own lender’s position from the wider historical record. It does not establish what happened on your conveyancing file or guarantee current mortgage availability.
Read Part 2 alongside the applicable general instructions, mortgage offer and case-specific correspondence. An absence of express wording should not be treated as proof of acceptance.
Does the present difficulty mean the original advice was inadequate?
A later mortgage problem does not, by itself, establish an earlier mistake.
Start with the original lease, Report on Title, mortgage papers and correspondence. What was the remaining term when you bought? What did your conveyancer explain about its significance, possible extension and future ownership?
Were you planning to sell soon, retain the flat for many years or refinance to fund an extension? What did you tell your advisers, and what advice followed?
Historical lender compliance and advice to the purchaser are related but separate questions. Satisfying the original lender does not settle whether the buyer received appropriate advice. A later refusal does not establish that the earlier advice was wrong.
If the present problem has made you question what you understood when buying, When I Bought’s short-lease page explores the purchase records and questions that may matter.
Keep the current transaction and historical investigation moving
For the sale, obtain a clear explanation of the obstacle and take advice on realistic options. Depending on the circumstances, these may involve further lender consideration, different borrowing arrangements or investigating a lease extension.
Do not assume that an alternative lender will accept the property or that an extension can be completed within the existing timetable.
For the historical investigation, preserve the original documents and the current written explanation of the problem. If you are considering a complaint or potential claim, obtain advice promptly about the relevant time limits.
What did the lender actually require when you bought?
A current lease-term requirement cannot answer a historical question. Start with the lender, the relevant date and the recorded wording.
Explore the Lexsure Lender Archive’s short-lease page to check available historical records and the report options.
Check historical short-lease lender requirements →
Historical evidence does not, by itself, establish negligence or determine whether a lender will lend today. If you are unsure which record you need, speak to Lexsure before ordering.
This article concerns general conveyancing issues in England and Wales and was checked on 1 November 2026. Numerical examples are hypothetical. Mortgage eligibility, legal responsibility and available extension routes require assessment for the particular transaction. About Conveyancing and the Lexsure Lender Archive are Lexsure publications and services.